10-13-2021, 09:13 AM
Thanks to both of you for your responses and ideas, they have been very helpful. I think Geoff's approach to scrolling most closely resembles what I have been trying to do. However my circumstances are slightly different in that my music tends to use a 3 stave system (vocals plus keyboard treble & bass) and in consequence it is typical for a score to be anywhere from 3 to 10 pages long which is a lot of page turns.
I generally use Musescore to create the score and that allows me to rearrange repeats and jumps in favour of a simple linear score. It can compress the score into a reduced number of pages, albeit with smaller font. It allows me to export the score as a pdf in portrait or landscape format.
My feet are already very busy with an octave worth of bass pedals, a sustain pedal and an effects pedal - so I don't want any more pedals to turn pages if I can help it.
Geoff's setup is very close to giving me what I need - except for the timing. It seems the gap between what MSP provides and what I think is needed is very small. Basically the initial delay needed before scrolling starts is already provided in MSP but in addition MSP would require a calculation of the required scroll speed for each page in the song "the current page". This can be derived from information already available in the MSP metronome (# of beats on current page, Tempo and Beat Subdivision).
I don't know how difficult it would be to change MSP to include this capability but I know there would be the following considerations for the user. The score would need to be linearised to remove repeats and jumps - but many users have already encountered and resolved this. Tempo changes or Time signature changes could not be accommodated in the middle of a song - but this only affects a small percentage of songs.
Do you think this would be a useful and feasible addition to MSP and how could it be moved forwards.
Thanks for your interest and help
Mike
I generally use Musescore to create the score and that allows me to rearrange repeats and jumps in favour of a simple linear score. It can compress the score into a reduced number of pages, albeit with smaller font. It allows me to export the score as a pdf in portrait or landscape format.
My feet are already very busy with an octave worth of bass pedals, a sustain pedal and an effects pedal - so I don't want any more pedals to turn pages if I can help it.
Geoff's setup is very close to giving me what I need - except for the timing. It seems the gap between what MSP provides and what I think is needed is very small. Basically the initial delay needed before scrolling starts is already provided in MSP but in addition MSP would require a calculation of the required scroll speed for each page in the song "the current page". This can be derived from information already available in the MSP metronome (# of beats on current page, Tempo and Beat Subdivision).
I don't know how difficult it would be to change MSP to include this capability but I know there would be the following considerations for the user. The score would need to be linearised to remove repeats and jumps - but many users have already encountered and resolved this. Tempo changes or Time signature changes could not be accommodated in the middle of a song - but this only affects a small percentage of songs.
Do you think this would be a useful and feasible addition to MSP and how could it be moved forwards.
Thanks for your interest and help
Mike