06-26-2015, 03:29 AM
(06-26-2015, 02:00 AM)sciurius Wrote: Interesting...
I think most of it stems from the practice of transposing by interval instead of key. When you say "I have a song in A, and I transpose it to B" the process is, indeed, deterministic. However, when you have a bunch of chords and want to transpose up 2 intervals, the case is different.
I'm one of those stupids that transpose by intervals. I also play Bb instead of A# and C# instead of Db...
While I can see how you're thinking as far as transposing by interval, I have to side with DTown on this. When I transpose, it's from Key X to Key Y, and I expect the correct chords that fit for Key Y.